Skip to main content

Author: jeffreyhoward

Litigation of your NC Injury Claim

Thankfully, most NC auto accident claims get settled without litigation. That’s a good thing for both parties. Litigation is expensive, time-consuming, and uncertain, so I would never say that it’s the best dispute resolution platform out there. Winston Churchill said of Democracy, “It’s the worst form of government, except for all of the other ones we’ve tried,” and this same sentiment might apply to trial by jury. Still, as much as we’d like to avoid it, sometimes you have to go through with it.

In making the decision to go to trial, it would help if you knew, at least in a nutshell, what the entire litigation process looked like. So here’s that nutshell for you:

Filing: First, as the Plaintiff we must file a Complaint. That’s a formal documentation of what you’re saying the bad guys did and you take it to the appropriate county clerk’s office, pay them some money, and boom, you’re a litigant. You then have to serve the Defendant (which costs money) in a prescribed way (which is often easier said than done) and after that the Defendant has 30 days (really 60) to file an Answer, which is a formal document that will state why the Defendant thinks the Plaintiff is full of $#%!.

Discovery: This is probably going to be the longest part of the litigation process. Discovery consists of two elements – written discovery and depositions. Written discovery is most easily described as asking tons of invasive and inappropriate questions on paper that the parties are then required to answer in 30 days (really 60) under oath. Depositions are question and answer sessions that are requested by the attorneys for the litigants, at which the deponent is asked questions under oath in the presence of a court reporter who is documenting every word. The discovery process is really about fact-finding so that each litigant knows what evidence supports or harms their respective claims. Mostly it’s the plaintiff and defendant who are deposed, but witnesses can be as well, and expert witness depositions are very important. Three things you should really take away about Discovery: First, it’s going to take a lot of time and effort on YOUR part, not just mine, so know that you’re essentially signing up for a part-time job. Second, it’s probably the most important part of the litigation process and can really make or break your claim. Third, it’s deceptively expensive. You will be paying the court reporter as well as for transcripts, which adds up quickly. More importantly, if you’re paying for an expert witness, here’s where you can really, really get in the hole. So be forewarned.

Mediation: Every case filed in Superior Court in NC must go to mediation unless excused by a Judge. A mediation is just a formal settlement conference refereed by a mediator, who does not make decisions in the case but just helps the parties to communicate. This costs money, too, but is often worth it, as most cases that are filed are settled at or before mediation. There will be considerable preparation work prior to the mediation, but the amount is really on a case by case basis.

Trial: This is the actual going to court, picking a jury, and going through the court room process. This can be time-consuming and immensely stressful. For the most part, the process here is too complicated to really right about, especially in that it may vary so much from case to case. But most of what you’ve seen on TV is both very right and very wrong, if that helps you any.

The process is expensive, imperfect, and uncertain. But maybe it’s your best chance at success, whatever that means, for your claim. Just talk to your attorney and ask as much as you can to know what you’re getting into before making such a big decision.

Why “but this is my first ticket!” is not a defense

Traffic Attorney

“BUT THIS IS MY FIRST TICKET!” is something I hear ALL the time when I explain what the likely outcome of an Orange or Chatham County speeding ticket might be. People sadly work under the mistaken assumption that if you’ve never had a ticket before, your first one is on the house. That just ain’t true.

Think of it this way: A speeding ticket is, whether you like it or not, an accusation of a crime. A small crime, but a crime nonetheless. Which means it’s like larceny, or arson, or murder. Do you get one free murder? Nope. Doesn’t work like that.

I know, that’s not an apples to apples comparison, precisely, but the premise holds true: Just because this is your first ticket doesn’t mean you’re going to get out of it without some sort of consequences. Does having a clean driving record potentially help your outcome? For sure! The ADA negotiating the ticket will very likely take that into consideration. But it ain’t getting dismissed just because it’s your first one.

I just thought you all should know.

Expectations are your Worst Enemy

Before you start thinking about what your North Carolina injury case is worth, consider what you’re basing your expectations on.

If you’re basing your expectations on what you WANT your case to be worth, that’s not a good foundation. Neither is what your Uncle Fred settled his case for in 1997. You might also be surprised to find out that the internet pretty much has no idea what it’s talking about. I could go on and on as to what NOT to base your claim value on…

But that begs the question: What SHOULD you base your claim value on? Well, if you hired a seasoned personal injury attorney with over 2 decades in this business (such as myself) then you should probably just trust what he has to say. There are TONS of factors to consider in valuing a case, including but not limited to: Venue, liability, causation concerns, potential legal defenses to liability, pre-existing conditions, objective v. subjective injuries, prior case settlements, prior verdicts, medical expenses, insurance coverage questions, liens, permanency of injury…and that’s just to name the main ones, not all of them!

If you’re not intimately familiar with the meaning and nuances of everything on that list (and then some), please do not be offended when I say that you are not the best source of an opinion as to the value of your case. Nor is your Uncle Fred.

Look. I get it. At the end of the day, resolving injury claims can solely be done via monetary reward, so whether we like it or not, it is about the money. So you’re certainly entitled to be curious as to what your case is worth. You can also have whatever opinion you want as to your own case value. But the point of this particular writing is this: Your expectations can really throw you for a loop in these situations, so the best advice I can give you as a personal injury is to throw your expectations out the window. They have no place here. You’ll never be on the jury hearing your case, so your opinion is not going to be relevant in the case evaluation. If you want to know what your case should be worth, ask an experienced North Carolina personal injury attorney and listen to their advice. And if you form an opinion without that advice, don’t be upset when your expectations are met because they probably simply aren’t realistic.

Duty to Mitigate Your Damages

North Carolina accident victims don’t get a fair shake after accidents for a LOT of reason, most of which can be laid at the feet of GOP legislators, but that’s for another blog post. One of the many rules that accident victims aren’t aware of and that comes back to bite them is the Duty to Mitigate Your Damages.

The duty to mitigate essentially means that if you have a proverbial tourniquet to stop the proverbial bleeding, you have to staunch it and you can’t blame the guy who accidentally cut your finger when you bleed out. Here’s the most common example of how that rule might mess up your day:

Let’s say you’re in an auto accident, not your fault, and it totals your vehicle. The bad guy’s insurance pays the “fair market value” (whether that’s “fair” or not is, yet again, for another blog post…) but you can’t find a car to buy and use for 6 weeks. You need your car to work, so in addition to your injuries, etc., you’re losing income for 6 weeks, all of which can be traced back to the original act of negligence of the bad guy driver. Yet, the Duty to Mitigate would probably preclude you from being able to recover the vast majority of that lost income for the 6 weeks after they paid you for your property damage. The law would say that after they paid you FMV for your vehicle, they were square, as it were, with you with regards to your property damage and by extension your property damage-related lost income.

I hear the rationale for why that’s fair; it’s not really fair to expect the bad guys or their carrier to go and find you a car that you’ll be happy with. I get it. BUT, at the same time, you can’t ride the stupid check to work and back! The money is NOT a car, so it’s not the same thing!

Now, with the right argument you might be able to get a little bit of that lost income because, Duty to Mitigate or not, there is a reasonable argument to be made that even with that check, you can’t turn that into a car in a day or even three, so maybe a short percentage of that 6 week absence might be a reasonable argument, but not a guaranteed one.

Once again, all this stuff is complicated which is why you should get a personal injury lawyer that knows what they’re talking about. Get me! 919-929-2992.

Hurt at Work? File a Form 18

If you’re hurt on the job and think you have a worker’s comp claim, do yourself a favor and file a Form 18 now. What’s that?

It’s this: https://www.ic.nc.gov/forms/form18.pdf

That form, as long as it’s filed within 30 days of your injury, meets all of the notice requirements of the NC Worker’s Comp Act. Your employer/their insurance company will find any reason to deny your benefits, so don’t get them this one. File that Form 18 ASAP after your injury.

Injury Claim Pitfalls

I could write a book on the various and sundry ways you can make your North Carolina personal injury claim worse. There are a lot. But these little nuggets are the most common that you should look out for…

Southern Hospitality/Taking the Blame

One of the things I like about the South is that, in general, we do tend to be pretty polite in public. How many times have you been holding a door for someone and then have a polite argument about how the other person should go first? That’s kinda nice. But this instinct can be killer for your claim. After an auto accident you will likely be interviewed by law enforcement and/or an insurance claims agent. If your Southern instinct to demur and not place the blame on someone else kicks in, that could lead to claims disaster. Always tell the truth, but never even come close to accepting blame, or even acknowledging partial fault, if that’s not definitely the truth! EVERYTHING you say can and will be used against you in this claim, so if it was the other guy’s fault, you say that and stick to it!

Health Insurance/Auto Insurance/What? What!?

Insurance is dumb. I’ll be the first to admit it. But in our current system it’s a necessity. But necessary or not, it can be super confusing. Do you use your health insurance if someone has liability insurance that should be paying for your medical expenses? What is this “Med Pay” stuff in my own auto policy? All of this can be confusing, but here’s the bottom line: North Carolina is NOT a PIP (personal injury protection) state, so you DO use your Health Insurance for auto-accident related injuries! Let me say that again louder for the people in the back. YOU DO USE YOUR HEALTH INSURANCE! Here’s the best way to look at it: Your health insurance is on the hook in NC, no matter who else might be on the hook in theory. Yes, your health plan might have a right to get paid back IF you get payment for those bills from someone else, but that’s way down the road. When you incur the health care bills, your health insurance is on the hook for them. Period. How does your auto “Med Pay” play into that? Well, that’s no fault coverage that you can access after any auto accident, but be careful when/how you access it, because lien-holders might have a right to it. That’s another blog post altogether, though, so call me for details on that one.

Tough Guy/Gal Syndrome

“Yeah, I’m a little banged up, but I think I’ll wait a few weeks to see if I really need treatment,” is a great attitude to absolutely shred your injury claim. Here’s the skinny: Insurance companies LOVE to take advantage of good intentions. You might be trying to be tough or trying not to “make a big deal” out of something, but if you’re hurt, you should seek treatment. If you don’t seek treatment, the insurance company is going to argue to your future jury that you must not have been hurt. So that week or two or three or whatever that you’re waiting, albeit for the kindest of purposes, gets used against you as “proof” that you weren’t really hurt in the first place. The bottom line is if you’re hurt after an accident, get checked out and go ahead and start whatever kind of treatment you need or you’ll regret it if you don’t.

Sadly, there are tons of other ways you people will act that will compromise your claim, but I can’t go into all of them. I wish it wasn’t so fraught, but insurance companies have come up with all kinds of tactics to avoid paying reasonable value for claims, so you have to get good advice fast to avoid falling prey to them. So if you’re hurt in an accident, call an attorney asap. Call me. 919-929-2992.

Mediation? What the heck is that?

If you have a worker’s compensation or auto accident injury claim in North Carolina, there’s a fairly high chance that you may be involved in a mediation at some point. So what the heck is a mediation anyway?

A mediation is a moderately formal meeting of two or more adverse parties to convene, under the guidance of a mediator, in an attempt to resolve the conflict between the parties. In some instances a mediation is mandatory in North Carolina, but not always. I tend to like them as a dispute resolution alternative and here are a few reasons why:

  • Your attorney does all the talking, really. You don’t have to be examined or cross examined or get all worked up about that. For the most part your attorney will do all the talking for you. Don’t get me wrong: You’ll be involved and your decision-making is critical but you won’t be under any pressure to “perform,” which is great.
  • The mediator is NOT a judge. The mediator, who is normally agreed to and assigned by the parties, is a non-partial, independent third party who gets paid no matter what so s/he doesn’t have a horse in the race. Generally, they’re just nice old lawyers or judges who like helping people figure stuff out. Often times you can really lean on their experience to help you gain a better understanding of the issues. Whereas a judge often tells you the outcome, a mediator only helps you to come to an outcome that you agree to. That’s way better in my opinion.
  • You’re not with the adverse party very long. Generally speaking, there is the opening where the mediator briefly explains the process, the plaintiff’s attorney recounts what the issues are, the defense attorney responds, and then you separate into different rooms. This is called “caucusing” which just means you’re separate and free to talk to your attorney and the mediator about what’s going on. When you’re in a caucus, you can confide in the mediator if you feel it’s necessary/appropriate, and tell them not to share that info, and they won’t. Plus, you get to confer with your attorney while the mediator is away and that allows you plenty of real-time reaction to what you’re learning.
  • You get to hear the other side. Everyone knows the strengths of their claims, but depending on your attorney’s style of practice, you may not know a great deal about the weaknesses of your claim, or how another party might perceive them. This is a great opportunity to hear the adverse parties’ viewpoints on your situation AND you get to have that filtered by an experienced, independent, NEUTRAL third party – the mediator – and that is worth its weight in gold. Maybe your case is great, but maybe it ain’t. This is where you often find out.
  • You have the power to decide. In a trial, the “finder of fact” gets to decide the outcome of your case. That’s normally a judge or a jury. But that takes the power of your outcome totally out of your hands. In a mediation, you get to agree or not. I have found throughout the years that clients really appreciate having the power to agree to a resolution of a claim to be very, well, empowering, for lack of a better word.

And that’s really not all of the benefits, that’s just all I can explain in a blog post. If you’re in a position to potentially resolve your case in a mediation, it’s a good opportunity to at minimum learn about your case and best case scenario get the best, most reasonable outcome possible.

Tips for Getting an Attorney for Your Speeding Ticket In NC

Traffic Attorney

There’s a very good chance you will need an attorney if you get a speeding ticket. It is the vast minority of ticket situations that allow for you to simply pay them off without long-term adverse consequences, so get some good legal advice.

The best way to get good advice is to know what you’ve got and what you want. Here are some tips to help you help yourself!

  • Know what you’re charged with. I can’t really tell you much about what I might be able to do to help or what needs to be done if I don’t know what you’re charged with. If you’re calling without the ticket in front of you, you should carry it with you. It isn’t that heavy.
  • Have the person charged available to speak. I know, I know, you want to help little Johnny because you’re a helicopter parent, or you want to help your boyfriend because he’s mostly useless. That’s fine, but have him there near the phone so he can answer questions about the situation if need be.
  • Know WHERE you were charged. Same as the first one, all of this information is on the ticket in case you forget where you were when it happened, but your potential attorney HAS to know the jurisdiction to give you an idea of what might be done or if s/he has any knowledge of what might done. Practices vary a lot between jurisdictions, so this is extra important.
  • Empty your cup. Don’t call an attorney with the idea that you’re going to tell them what needs to happen. It’s cool to have goals and all, but you’re SEEKING advice, not giving it, so listen up.
  • Stay local. I’ll be the first to tell you that local guys tend to do better locally. That’s not to say that I can’t handle a Wake County ticket, but if it’s something out of the ordinary, I will refer that out because my experience is that if you need a little extra because your charge is a little extra, then you are better off calling someone who is in that court house semi-daily.

That should help set you on the road to success. Just don’t try to go too fast on that road. You don’t want another ticket.

But it’s my first ticket!!!!

Traffic Attorney

When you get a ticket in North Carolina you should take it seriously. Tickets aren’t just about the dollar amount on the paper you were given (if there is one). They can have HUGE impacts on your future insurance rates for years to come and MIGHT even result in the loss of your license. Tickets can be a big deal!

Most of you know this, so you naturally want to use everything you can think of to defend yourself against the consequences. But I’m here to tell you, “But this is my first ticket!” is NOT a valid defense.

Sure, if you’ve got a clean record that can help you in negotiating a better outcome. But PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THINGS HOLY get the idea that you get one free ticket out of your head. This is NOT a thing.

If you’ve got a speeding ticket in NC, you should seek legal advice immediately, preferably from an attorney in the same geographic area as where you received the ticket. Call me at 919-929-2992.

Empty Your Cup

I learned a great lesson from a story early in my life and I’ve found that lesson to be relevant almost every day of my life since. It’s particularly relevant when you are going to seek help from someone who is an expert in their field. Here’s the story:

A young man who had begun studying a subject and who had discussed said subject with his friends and family decided it was time to further his studies in the field by seeking an acknowledged master in the field. The teacher he sought had studied the field in a rigorous academic setting for years, had been tested by other recognized experts in the field, AND had decades of practical experience working hands-on within that field.

The young man finally found the teacher and asked her to teach him. She said that first they should have a cup of coffee and discuss things. The teacher began to set out cups and to pour the coffee. As she filled the young man’s cup, it began to overflow, but she continued to pour. The young man exclaimed, “Teacher! My cup is already full!”

The teacher replied, “Exactly. When you come seeking knowledge you must first empty the cup of the knowledge that you are looking to improve upon. If your cup is already full, I cannot fill it.”

This is something we should all carry with us. We might think we know something, or even a lot, about a certain subject. We might have talked to Uncle Joe or Cousin Suzy or our friend Aaron and gotten their take on it, but we must consider the source of our so-called “knowledge.” Did we learn what we think we learned from actual experts in this field? Did the people we discussed this with give us hard-won, field-tested practical knowledge they had gained through study and work, OR did they simply confirm our own bias/prejudice and we sucked it up just because it felt good to be validated?

If you really want to learn, empty your cup. If you seek the information/guidance/assistance of an actual expert in a field, then dispose of the dross that you’ve accumulated in your head from non-authorities. Do not insult the practical experience of the expert whose help you’re seeking by contesting it against the anecdotal drivel you’ve allowed yourself to be poisoned by.

If, on the other hand, you just want to keep believing what you already believe, or thinking what you already think, just because that feels comforting then do that. But don’t try to compare your feelings to the expert’s knowledge. They are not the same.